Burma Partnership, Strengthening Cooperation for a Free Burma
Signup Now!
Join our mailing list for latest news and information about Burma.

14 July – 20 July: Flurry of Rumor and Counter Rumor Regarding Repatriation is Detrimental to Refugees

July 22, 2014

20-June-2011-SIMON ROUGHNEEN-The IrrawaddyA week ago, rumors began doing the rounds that the Thai military plans to repatriate the 130,000 or so displaced persons from Burma living in nine camps in Thailand along the length of the Burma-Thailand border in the relatively immediate future. The rumors started when General Prayuth Chan-o-cha, Head of the National Council for Peace and Order (NCPO), mentioned that the refugee issue had been discussed with Senior General Min Aung Hlaing, Commander-in-Chief of the Burma Army. On 14 July, the Bangkok Post then quoted an unnamed Thai military source saying that working teams have sorted 130,000 refugees into three groups as part of preparations to send them home, a process expected to take around a year or more. A Burma Border Guard Force officer also told Mizzima on 15 July that armed ethnic groups in Karen State would allegedly cooperate in the resettlement of refugees on their return home.

However, according to DVB, Colonel Weerachon Sukondhadpatipak, a spokesman for the Thai military, refuted the rumors: “I don’t think this [repatriation] will happen at this moment. It is an issue we need to solve, but it doesn’t mean we are sending the Burmese people back to [Burma],” Weerachon said. “It is a long process that needs to be discussed with all concerned parties.” Indeed, nationalities would first need to be verified and people head-counted.

Furthermore, Iain Hall, Senior Coordinator for the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), reassured people that “UNHCR is not aware of any changes in [Thai] government policy, or of any government timeframe to repatriate refugees.” Duncan McArthur, Director of the Border Consortium, a coalition of 10 international non-governmental organizations delivering humanitarian assistance to camps on the border, confirmed this view, emphasizing that “there has not been any policy change regarding refugee return since the [NCPO] assumed power in Thailand. This was the consistent message from the Thai Army and the Internal Security Operations Command (ISOC) to refugee leaders […] during [meetings in] June.”

Then, on 17 July, the Thai Department of Information, of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, clarified its position on the refugee situation through a public statement. The statement claimed that both sides have committed to work closely together “to prepare for a safe return in the future in accordance with humanitarian and human rights principles,” and also emphasized that “the discussion was in general terms with no specific timeframe.” Furthermore, the statement spoke of the importance of “a sustainable return…in safety and dignity,” and highlighted the fact that “further discussions are needed with all relevant partners and International Organizations, including UNHCR, in this preparation to ensure the success of the process.”

It is imperative that both the Burma and Thai authorities are clear and transparent as regards their intentions. The Thai authorities have set out their principles, and it is only to be hoped that they now honor them. However, the Burma Government must do the same. The current flurry of rumor and counter rumor is causing panic, confusion, anxiety and frustration among the refugees; they have already suffered enough, and it is vital that they do not suffer any further – either from the many current uncertainties as to their status and future, or from persecution or human rights abuses if they are repatriated prematurely. An unambiguous, principled and firm statement from the Burma Government would be a positive start. But what the refugees are really looking for is a genuine commitment by all parties to the protection of their human rights, and to their inclusion in the ongoing dialogue. Recent developments have only served to further undermine their already precarious position.

We reiterate our calls from a month ago, namely that representatives of the refugee camps and of community-based organizations must be included in any future discussions about the status of refugees or their potential repatriation; that repatriation of refugees must only take place when circumstances are appropriate, when it is genuinely safe to return, and when all refugees’ human rights are guaranteed by the Burma Government; and, most importantly, that such repatriation must be completely voluntary.

Finally, it should be the Burma Government – and specifically President Thein Sein – whom the Thai authorities should be meeting: the implication from recent developments is that the Burma Army is still running the show. It is also worth remembering – should anyone have forgotten – that it is the Burma Army whom most of the refugees were fleeing in the first place. It is easy to see why refugees might be suspicious and cynical about Burma Army assurances, despite the winning words of the Thai authorities.

News Highlights

In Sagaing Region, a court sentences 18 farmers to prison, terms varying from three months to three years on charges of trespassing and damages, after the farmers attempted to plow a land that is being claimed by a sugar cane company

Inside Burma

A new party called Chin League for Democracy is formed and registered under Union Election Commission to take part in 2015 elections

In Magwe region, Magwe town chairman and secretary of National League for Democracy (NLD) and a member of 88 Generation Peace and Open Society (88GPOS) are tried for using a loudspeaker without permission during a rally led by NLD and 88GPOS for constitutional amendment

In Tavoy, Tenasserim region, ten men and nine women are sentenced to up to nine months in prison and fines of around $10 US on several charges including disturbing government officials on duty, weapons possession, and assaulting government officials over a land confiscation case

Shwe Mann, speaker of Union Parliament, warns a lower house not to use the word “revolutionary” when referring to ethnic armed groups, after lower house MP Nang Wah Nu referred to Shan State Army-North as a “revolutionary group”

In Kachin State, Burma Army kills one soldier and arrests two officers from Kachin Independence Army

Ta’ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) says at least 178 Burma Army soldiers have been killed and more than 100 soldiers have been wounded in conflict against TNLA over the past six months

In Rangoon, two activists are arrested and sentenced to six months in prison for distributing pamphlets that accused President Thein Sein’s government of abusing power

People in Rakhine State suffer from heavy rains and flash-floods, resulting in shortages of food, drinking water and medicine


While China and Burma’s government officials hold their annual meeting on Combating Human Trafficking in China, in northern Shan State, a man and a woman is arrested for selling their daughters to human traffickers who smuggle victims into China to marry Chinese men

North Korean Embassy in Rangoon makes an unofficial invitation to journalists in Burma to travel to their country if they are willing to meet their media sources to learn more about the current situation in North Korea

Bangkok Bank Executive Vice President, Chaiyarit Anuchitworawong, says they are awaiting a banking license to operate in Burma and will bring more Thai investors into the country

Japanese companies, KDDI Corporation and Sumitomo Corporation sign an agreement with Burma’s Posts and Telecommunications to jointly operate a mobile phone service by investing 200 billion yen ($190 billion US dollars) over 10 years on building up the telecom infrastructure in Burma


UK launches its first British Chamber of Commerce in Burma to work with local Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce, which is the first European country to set up a chamber of commerce in the country after EU lifted economic sanctions against Burma in 2013

The US accuses Burma authorities of resorting to police-state tactics after five journalists from a weekly magazine received 10 years of hard labor for publishing a story about a weapons factory


Burma Military Facility Hides Secrets From the World
By John Artebury
The Irrawaddy

Hatred as politics in Myanmar
By Kyaw Win
Asia Times

Latest from the Blog

A Return to the Bad Old Days for Freedom of Expression
By Burma Partnership


Take Action! Write a letter to President Thein Sein calling for all charges to be dropped against eight Chin human rights defenders who are facing imprisonment for peacefully protesting against impunity for sexual violence in Chin State

Approximately 20 journalists from several news agencies in Sittwe, Rakhine State, take part in a prayer campaign for the release of Unity Journal news journalists who were sentenced to 10 years in jail and in Irrawaddy Region, 21 journalists carry out a prayer campaign at Shwemudaw Pagoda to call for Burma government to drop recent sentences and charges pressed against the media workers of the Unity Journal and Bi-Mon Te Nay Weekly news

In Rangoon, over 700 workers from Korea owned Master Sports Footwear Factory protest in front of South Korean Embassy to demand help from the officials after the owner closed the factory without making any notice or paying their wages

Statements and Press Release

Myanmar: One Year on, President’s Promise to Release All Prisoners of Conscience Remains Unfulfilled
By Amnesty International

Burma: Drop Charges against Chin Activists; End Impunity for Sexual Violence
By Chin Human Rights Organization

Burma: Increased Number of Political Prisoners Calls for Renewed International Pressure
By FIDH and Altsean-Burma

Civil Society’s Recommendations to the ASEAN Ministers Meeting (AMM) in the Review and Amendment of the Terms of Reference (TOR) of the ASEAN
By Human Rights Working Group, International NGO Forum on Indonesian Development and 30 members of civil society organizations from ASEAN member countries

Displaced Persons from Myanmar in Thailand
By Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Kingdom of Thailand

This post is in: Weekly Highlights