Burma Partnership, Strengthening Cooperation for a Free Burma
Signup Now!
Join our mailing list for latest news and information about Burma.

10 – 16 February: Upcoming Census is a Grave Threat to National Reconciliation and Should Be Postponed

February 17, 2014

Myanmar census a Pandora's Box for ethnic minoritiesThe upcoming national census, scheduled for 30 March and the first conducted in Burma for more than three decades, is proving to be one of the most divisive issues on Burma’s agenda. Representatives of Burma’s numerous ethnic nationalities, as well as of smaller ethnic sub-groups, are raising vociferous objections to the census. Many feel that it violates their right to identity. Such objections generally work in two opposing directions, which only serves to highlight the complexity and dangers of such an exercise. On the one hand, smaller ethnic sub-groups often feel excluded, threatened or incorrectly classified if they cannot identify as their own ethnic sub-group. For example, the Palaung people have expressed a desire to identify themselves solely as Palaung rather than Shan, on the basis that they are descended from Mon-Khmer and not Shan-Tai ancestry. Indeed, the Palaung State Liberation Front recently issued a statement rejecting the census’s categorization of the Palaung people as one of 33 Shan sub-groups. On the other hand, larger ethnic groups feel that their own wider national identity and cause is undermined if ethnic sub-groups do not identify as, say, Shan. The same dilemmas and frictions are being reported in Chin, Kachin and Karen States. Indeed, such tensions within each state and region are a microcosm of what is happening in Burma overall. Some groups have recognized the census’s value in terms of development, health and education, but have explicitly denounced the fact that ethnic categorization is included in the census. In a letter to Parliamentary Speaker Shwe Mann, 23 Kachin civil society organizations called for either a postponement of the census or the complete omission of Question 8, which asks for ethnic or tribal identification. Ethnic Chin activists recently wrote to the National Census Commission, requesting at least a 30-day delay. Furthermore, the census represents a grave risk to rights and security in the context of recent anti-Muslim and anti-Rohingya violence in Arakan State and across Burma. Despite being classified as “non-citizens,” Rohingya Muslims can identify themselves as Rohingya with the code 194, yet there are concerns that data collectors may simply write “Bengali” for Rohingya, thereby re-igniting smoldering tensions about citizenship. Fears have also been voiced that Muslims of other ethnicities might be told to identify themselves as “Muslim,” which is of course a religious rather than ethnic affiliation, rather than as the ethnic group to which they belong. Since Muslims were allegedly intentionally under-recorded in the last census in 1983 due to political sensitivities at the time, there is a significant risk this time of a violent response to the number of Muslims in Burma if the census is accurately conducted and Muslims are required to state their religion over their ethnicity. Finally, there has been no transparency or consultation with ethnic groups about the census. Some groups have welcomed the fact that the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) is assisting the Burma government, on the basis that it lends the process some legitimacy. Yet the lack of transparency and consultation is a damning indictment of the UN’s – and donors’ – role in the census, while the accusations of inaccuracy and divisiveness only serve to further undermine the credibility of these parties. Moreover, there are real fears about the logistics of collecting the data, both in terms of authorities using the correct forms and accessing remote areas or conflict zones, which would have implications for the accuracy of data recorded on the Kachin, the Palaung of northern Shan State, and the Wa, in particular. It is clear that this census represents a Pandora’s Box of potential ethnic tensions and conflict. At a time when the Burma government claims to be striving to secure a sustainable peace deal with the armed ethnic groups and cementing political reforms before the 2015 national elections, the timing and nature of the census is strange, to say the least. It risks jeopardizing national reconciliation, undermining the peace process, and exacerbating inter-communal violence. Therefore this census should be postponed, and only revisited once a comprehensive political settlement has been reached with all ethnic armed groups, political reforms have been properly institutionalized after the 2015 national elections, and inter-communal violence has been tackled head-on and defused. If not, “the census process should be urgently amended to focus only on key demographic questions, postponing those which are needlessly antagonistic and divisive—on ethnicity, religion, citizenship status—to a more appropriate moment,” as International Crisis Group recommends in its “Conflict Alert.” If the census does include such provocative questions, answers should be based on the choice of the people. Every individual should be allowed to freely state which ethnic group he or she identifies with the most – including stipulating mixed race if applicable – without pressure from anyone, whether the Burma government or other ethnic groups. Such questions are vital, because they have important implications for political representation. The Burma government cannot afford to get this wrong, especially not now, at this highly volatile stage in the country’s reform process.

News Highlights

President Thein Sein hints at decentralized federal union and explicitly refers to the Panglong Agreement during his Union Day speech, yet ethnic activists doubt the sincerity of his words

Government declares up to 80,000 shanty-town dwellers in Rangoon’s Dagon Post Township illegal squatters, who now face eviction in the largest displacement by forced eviction in Burma’s history

 Inside Burma

NLD and 88 Generation Peace and Open Society Group vow to collaborate on reform and amend the 2008 Constitution before the 2015 national elections, with NLD supporters and 88 Generation leaders calling for constitutional reform Parliament passes new conservation law ensuring the protection of conservation areas by law and guarantees environmental policies to govern business and development projects Upper House passes a new version of the Union Development Fund Bill after Parliament made amendments to address government concerns, with all military MPs voting against the bill One third of MPs absent from Parliament at a recent regular session, despite warnings from Parliamentary Speaker Thura Shwe Mann Burma Army holding 10 Mansi villagers captive while they continue their attacks in and around the village of Nam Lim Pa in Mansi Township, southern Kachin State according to Free Burma Rangers, while Burma Army launches deadly incursion into KIA-held territory near Bhamo Township on pretext of halting illegal logging The Shan Ethnic Affairs Organization denies training of monks and defends training from Burma Armed Forces despite a controversial photo of Buddhist monks holding firearms All-Burma Students Democratic Front honor 34 members killed in Karenni State since the beginning of their armed struggle against the Burma Army in 1988 Major conference on security, communal and religious conflict will take place in April with ethnic leaders in Arakan State, but the conference excludes Rohingya representative while several villagers are still missing after the Du Chee Yar Tan village massacre in Maungdaw Township, Arakan State Plain-clothed police arrests activist Thaw Zin on “criminal charges” for protesting against the Chinese-backed Letpadaung copper mine in Sagaing Region while the police refuses to accept a complaint over the beating of Thaw Zin upon his arrest Authorities apprehend six farmers and seven face arrest in relation to land confiscations by the Burma army in Bago Region while a police crackdown insures three protester in Bago Region Burma prepares to ratify the Chemical Weapons Convention while the Unity journalists stand trial for exposing a secret chemical weapons factory Photoshopped image of President Thein Sein prompts media ethics debate while Burma government fails to reflect on recent media reforms in legislation and journalists raise alarm over recent restrictions on visas for journalists following reports on alleged massacre in Maungdaw Township, Arakan State Burma to hold first ever ASEAN Youth Forum, scheduled for Moulmein, Mon State


Thailand deports 1,300 Rohingya back to Burma yet releases more than 600 prisoners, despite 10,000 still detained amid accusations of discrimination against Burmese prisoners United Wa State Army (UWSA) selects 30 fighters for pilot training in China, according to members of other ethnic armed groups who have visited the Wa headquarters in northern Shan State, a report denied by the UWSA and the Chinese Embassy in Burma

88 Generation activist Ko Aung Gyi assassinated in yet another attack on Burma activists in Malaysia, while Arakan League for Democracy Chairman, U Aye Thar Aung, says that there are over 80,000 migrant workers from Arakan State in Malaysia


Protesters greet UN Special Rapporteur Tomás Ojea Quintana in Sittwe, Arakan State, due to his alleged bias in favour of the Rohingya

Parliamentary Speaker Thura Shwe Mann discusses constitutional amendments, the crisis in Arakan State and Burma’s national debt with German President Joachim Gauck while the first Burma-Germany business forum highlights the interest of German businesses in Burma


Rape and Human Trafficking – Is This Burmese Democracy? By Dr Azeem Ibrahim The Huffington Post Suu Kyi Should Avoid Presidency By Gwynne Dyer Otago Daily Times

This post is in: Weekly Highlights